Tesla OEM floor mats vs 3W

What each one actually is

Tesla Shop Model Y All-Weather Interior Liners: floor set only (driver, passenger, second row), Tesla logo, OEM-like fit. Live Juniper SKU we checked is $240 (seen Aug 13, 2026). Frunk and trunk sold separate. 2020–2024 / legacy Y is a different year on that page — use the year selector. Highland 3 All-Weather Interior Liners are $225, floor only, 2024+ / Highland — not a Model Y mat.

3W Thorex (Juniper Prem/Perf): one Amazon box of TPE — floor + frunk + trunk + sub-trunk, about $256 (seen Aug 13, 2026). TPE tub look, not a factory carpet match. Does not fit 2026 Model Y Standard. Not a legacy Y mat. The Juniper ranking crowns it Best Overall for Premium and Performance.

3W’s legacy Y Thorex is a different ASIN — 9-piece 5-seat floor + cargo for 2020–2024/2025, not Juniper, Amazon ~$226.99. Neither 3W listing fits 2026 Standard Juniper. The verified Standard floor+cargo full set on the ranking is LASFIT.

Coverage, not a beauty contest

OEM: less coverage than the 3W full kit. Floor only. Spend more if OEM-like fit matters most.

3W: cargo in the same box. TPE, not a factory carpet match. Jowua’s Juniper liner card says remove the Tesla carpet mats first — the factory carpets and the Tesla Shop all-weather liners are not the same product.

TuxMat is the high-sidewall other path on the mats ranking. It is not in the WeatherTech / MAXpider / 3W compare grid, and it is not a row on this page.

Buy the ranking for your floor

• Juniper Y mats3W Thorex #1 for Prem/Perf. Tesla liners. LASFIT Standard.
• WeatherTech vs MAXpider vs 3WJuniper column is 3W TPE vs name-brand liners. TuxMat is not in that grid.
• Mats by generationHighland 3 Tesla liners, legacy Y 3W, Model Y L Teslaunch.