1
🏆 Best Overall
Spigen armrest cover
Best fix if the armrest lid is already shiny.
✓ Fits: Model Y L · Juniper Y 2025–26 · Highland 3 2024–26 Not 2017–2023 Model 3 or 2020–early 2025 Model Y (Spigen sells a different cover for those).
Watch out. On Spigen’s page, don’t pick the 2021–23 / 2021–24 option; that’s the older car.
Why we ranked it
Slip-on TPE, no adhesive.
Model Y L · Juniper Y · Highland 3, all trims
The armrest lid wears and goes shiny. This slip-on TPE cover needs no adhesive. The Amazon title names Model Y Juniper, Model Y L and Model 3 Highland, all trims (Standard, Premium, Performance). Also sold at Spigen.com. Rated 4.6 from 1,314 on Amazon (Sep 24, 2026). It’s an armrest lid cover, not a console tray, so it isn’t a Wigoo or Motrobe alternative.