Floor mats · compare · 2026
WeatherTech vs 3D MAXpider vs cheap TPE.
Three columns. Two generations. Buy the floor you actually have. Juniper (2025–26) is not legacy Y (2020–early 2025). Cheap TPE is 3W.
TuxMat is not in this grid. It is the high-sidewall other path on the mats ranking. This sheet is name-brand liner vs factory-look carbon vs one-box TPE cargo kit.
Fitment first. Then coverage, then whether the reviews exist. Prices and Amazon ratings seen Aug 13, 2026. A “fits 2020–2026 Model Y” listing is usually wrong.
Juniper Model Y (2025–26)
Updated Aug 13, 2026
| WeatherTech | 3D MAXpider | Cheap TPE (3W) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who it’s for | You already trust WeatherTech and will wait for volume. Floor only. We are not crowning it. | Factory-look carbon. Two Amazon boxes. Thin proof. We are not crowning it. | Premium or Performance Juniper. One box: floor + cargo. Not 2026 Standard. |
| SKU | FloorLiner HP · B0FLF6952V | Kagu split. Front B0F8PRK5B7 + rear B0F8PP27MN. Not one box. | Thorex B0F2FFNT3X. Alt in this cell only: B0F9Y1R93G — not the Thorex cargo set. |
| Coverage | Floor only. | Front + rear floor. Cargo/frunk not in these ASINs. | Floor + frunk + trunk + sub-trunk. Alt is not that cargo set. |
| Look | Name-brand liner. | Factory-look carbon texture. | TPE tub look. Not a factory carpet match. |
| Price (Aug 13, 2026) | about $279 | Front ~$142.99 + rear ~$76.99. Combined ~$220. | Thorex about $256. Alt about $169.99. |
| Reviews | Four Amazon reviews. No star rating. | Front 16 reviews. Rear 8. Too small to trust a rating. | Thorex 4.7 from 1,579. Alt 4.7 from 1,514. |
| Caveat | Price is the high one. Wait for real volume, or buy it because you already trust WeatherTech. | Do not buy the Highland 3 MAXpider SKU for a Y. Front and rear sold separate. | Thorex Amazon title: Not for Standard. Alt B0F9Y1R93G is a different listing; US amazon.com title is “Not Standard.” Do not mix them. Not a legacy Y mat. |
| Buy |
Verdict. 3W Thorex is the Juniper pick if you have Premium or Performance and want cargo in the same box. WeatherTech is the expensive name with four reviews — we are not crowning it. MAXpider is two ASINs and not enough volume. Highest sidewalls are on the ranking, not this grid.
Legacy Model Y (2020–early 2025)
Updated Aug 13, 2026
| WeatherTech | 3D MAXpider | Cheap TPE (3W) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who it’s for | You already trust WeatherTech. Floor only. Confirm the year. | 5-seat 2021–2025 factory-look carbon. Confirm a 2025 Y is pre-Juniper. | 5-seat pre-Juniper who wants the 9-piece cargo set. Not Juniper. |
| SKU | FloorLiner · B08XN3DFYM · parts 4416491-4415972 | Kagu B0936RH9SH · 5-seat 2021–2025. Same parent splits a Juniper child — do not pick that one. | Thorex 9-pc B0BZ48ZNRM · 2020–2024/2025. Not for Juniper. |
| Coverage | 1st + 2nd row floor only. No frunk/cargo. | 5-seat floor set. Not 7-seat. | 9-piece 5-seat floor + cargo. 2020 Y: revised mount only. |
| Look | Name-brand liner. | Factory-look carbon texture. | TPE tub look. Not a factory carpet match. |
| Price (Aug 13, 2026) | about $233.90 | about $165 | ~$226.99 |
| Reviews | 4.3 from 52 | 4.7 from 861 | 4.7 from 1,622 — parent-grouped with other 3W Y SKUs. Confirm the pre-Juniper 5-seat full set. |
| Caveat | Listing does not say “not Juniper.” 2026-up is a different WeatherTech part. A 2025 Juniper still needs a check. Confirm year in ConfirmedFit. | Title says 2021–2025; one bullet only lists 2021–2024. Not the Highland 3 SKU. | 5-seat only. Not Juniper. Do not mix with the Juniper 3W ASINs above. |
| Buy |
Verdict. In this trio, 3W is the cargo kit with volume — not for Juniper. MAXpider is the cheaper carbon floor set; confirm a 2025 is pre-refresh. WeatherTech is floor only and does not say not-Juniper, so check ConfirmedFit. Highest sidewalls are on the ranking, not this grid.
Highland Model 3 (2024–26)
A hole in this trio. The only verified column is 3D MAXpider Kagu B0CY3QD5BG — about $220, 4.8 from 63, floor only, Highland 2024–26. We do not have WeatherTech or 3W Highland ASINs, so there is no three-column table. TuxMat Highland B0D45WXKPM is the high-sidewall other path on the ranking — not in this grid. Not a Model Y mat. Not 2017–23 Model 3.